On November 17, Nvidia released its first earnings report since Jensen Huang stepped down: quarterly revenue of $115.8 billion, up 103 percent year on year, the first quarter above $100 billion in the company's history. The stock rose more than 5 percent after the close.
At the earnings call the same day, board chair Harvey Jones was blunt. The board had unanimously accepted his resignation, and it did "not plan" to have him return as chief executive.
Hours before that call, Huang had issued his first public statement since leaving: if the board judged that his return served the best interests of shareholders, employees, the company and the United States, he "would be honored to answer those calls."
On one side, 180,000 signatures. On the other, a single phrase: not planning to. This is not the end of a gossip story. It is two kinds of authority changing hands.
What Those 180,000 Signatures Say
Look at the petition closely first, because Chinese-language commentary got this wrong at the very first step.
It is called "Stand With Jensen," which looks like fan support. But what Agence France-Presse quoted is this: the letter asks Nvidia's board to bring Huang back while an independent investigation establishes the facts, and the organizers' stated reason is that "Jensen Huang deserves due process, not trial by public opinion."
It is not a hold-your-horses document. Its demand is harder: put the man back before the investigation ends.
The one actually arguing for slowness is a different document. Brad Gerstner of Altimeter and Gavin Baker of Atreides Capital wrote jointly to the board asking that the search for the next chief executive be "slow, deliberate and thoughtful," putting "all options on the table, including the potential return of Jensen Huang."
One document wants the man back. The other wants the process slowed down. Both have been compressed into a single headline: 180,000 people support him.
The composition of the signatures deserves a look too. According to tabulations by Reuters and Tencent News, about 94,000 of the 180,000 describe themselves as Nvidia shareholders, and more than 9,000 as current employees, roughly one fifth of the workforce. Every identity is self-reported and the site does not verify any of it. That has to be said plainly, or the numbers get treated as official statistics.
Shareholders dominating the list is itself the point: what worries them is not Huang's marriage. It is the position in their own accounts.
One Phrase: He Learned a Lesson
Trump's words were these: "I certainly wouldn't mind seeing him come back. He may come back. A lot of people want him back." The same day he added: "I think he learned a big lesson."
In English-language public speech, "learned a lesson" is a highly formulaic phrase of absolution. Its function is not to judge right from wrong but to convert irreversible shame into a reversible story of growth: you made a mistake, you suffered, you evolved, you may return. The grammar recurs in addiction recovery, juvenile justice and corporate crisis management. It assumes a person is an iterable system, that an error is a bug rather than a collapse of the underlying architecture.
The problem is who defines the lesson, and who signs off on it.
If the judge is God, or conscience, or family, then only he knows whether the lesson landed. But the judges here are a public company, a board of directors and a United States congressional inquiry. Reports say Congress is preparing to open an investigation into Huang. At this point "he learned a lesson" cannot rest on the man's own declaration. It has to be underwritten by process.
Trump was not delivering a moral verdict either. He was doing something else: translating a corporate governance crisis back into a plain-folks script about a capable man who tripped. That plays well with his voters, because the strong man errs, admits it and returns, which is the redemption arc American individualism likes best.
The paradox sits here: the people shouting "give him a chance" are the ones skipping the real question of what standard a chance would be measured against.
Asked whether he backed Huang's return, Sam Altman answered with restraint. He said he did not feel he knew enough to answer, that Huang had always been a hero to him, but that heroes have flaws too. Altman himself lived through being removed by his board in 2023 and coming back, yet he would not lend out his own script. The same plot on a different stage ends differently.
Charisma Meets Bureaucracy
Weber explained a hundred years ago that charismatic authority fears institutionalization above all. Huang is a textbook case: in 33 years he took a graphics card company to the top of global market capitalization, with the black leather jacket, the habit of replying to engineers directly, and, according to CNN, more than 50 people reporting to him one on one. The whole personality was welded into the Nvidia brand.
But Nvidia is not SpaceX, not Google, not Meta.
It has no dual-class structure. Huang holds roughly 871 million shares directly and indirectly, 3.58 percent, with no extra voting rights. According to disclosures from the 2026 annual meeting, BlackRock holds 7.43 percent, Vanguard 7.31 percent, State Street 4.25 percent and Fidelity 3.50 percent, about 22 percent across the four, with the rest scattered among thousands of institutions and none near a controlling stake. This is a standard one-share-one-vote public company.
According to a review by 21st Century Business Herald, Article 32 of Nvidia's bylaws is explicit: any officer may be removed at any time, without any prior finding of misconduct, on the affirmative vote of a majority of directors in office. Article 28 confirms that the chief executive is an officer.
In other words, the founder label carries no veto in this company.
That also explains something else, and it is a detail easily missed: the board created a position that did not previously exist, a first-ever board chair, and gave it to Harvey Jones, the former chief executive of Synopsys. The man sitting in the chair at the November 17 call was him. The seat was newly installed, and the occupant newly appointed.
Precedents are not scarce. In 2018, Intel chief executive Brian Krzanich resigned after a relationship with an employee violated company policy. In 2019, McDonald's chief executive Steve Easterbrook was fired over a consensual relationship with an employee. Both cases applied governance provisions directly, without any discussion of whether the man's contributions were too large to be waived.
Look the other way and Google and Meta used dual-class shares to lock voting power with their founders, who can keep control without being chief executive. Nvidia has no such insurance. So when something like this happens, it can only follow the standard motions: independent directors open an investigation led by outside counsel, in this case Wachtell, Lipton; the board unanimously accepts the resignation, effective immediately, announced on November 12; chief financial officer Colette Kress becomes interim chief executive.
One detail here is worth remembering: the board did not push him out. On November 8 he wrote an open letter to employees admitting infidelity to his wife. On November 11 the board accepted the resignation. On November 12 the announcement went out. He chose how to step down. The board chose when.
Trump's Words Are a Political Price
Do not read Trump's statement as a bit of gossip commentary.
The Washington Post reviewed his financial disclosures on November 16: as of the end of August, his own Nvidia holdings were worth between $13 million and $62 million, up from a range of $615,000 to $1.3 million at the end of 2024. The White House says the president does not pick stocks himself and that the portfolio is handled by an independent financial manager.
The same week, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent was arguing the opposite: Nvidia needs thorough reform and the next chief executive must come from outside. According to Axios, he also demanded a preliminary conclusion on export-control issues within 10 days. That was aimed at where chips flow, not at setting a timetable for this investigation.
So Trump's "wouldn't mind" stacks at least three layers: for voters, a boss who admitted a mistake, can come back and keeps the market rising; for Silicon Valley, a word passed to tech donors; for the industry, a door left slightly ajar.
Inside the White House, chip controls, AI infrastructure and Silicon Valley lobbying were never in step to begin with. Bessent's objection draws the boundary instead: whether Huang returns is no longer an HR question. It is Washington, Wall Street and Silicon Valley arguing over who should carry AI power.
Who Gets to Define a Mistake
Move the camera off Huang and look at this side of the screen.
On the Chinese internet the argument splits in two. One camp says it is a private matter and that moralizing about a tycoon is out of line. The other says a chief executive sleeping with a direct subordinate is an abuse of power and the board did the right thing.
They look like they are arguing about him. They are arguing about something more fundamental: what sets the tolerance threshold modern society grants to the outstanding.
Judge by results, and he built the most valuable company in the world, so can a private matter be offset against that? Judge by process, and whether a relationship with a direct subordinate violated company policy and affected disclosure has nothing to do with performance and must be investigated. Judge by feeling, and are we so hungry for a technological savior that we cannot bear to see him go?
None of these three logics convinces the others, because they are not on the same scale. The confusion around 180,000 signatures comes precisely from that mismatch: some signed for "do not let the stock collapse," some for "do not let Silicon Valley lose its soul," some for "due process must not be replaced by public opinion," and all of it was flattened into one button.
The genius of platform petitions is to compress a complex governance dispute into a binary switch. Pressing it feels good. Nobody tells you whether you are backing a man or a set of standards you have not sorted out yourself.
The Machine Still Turns. Then What.
The earnings gave a direct answer: revenue of $115.8 billion, data center revenue of $107.6 billion, guidance of about $130 billion for the fourth quarter, all above expectations. The board had approved a $150 billion increase to the share repurchase authorization in September, disclosed with the results, leaving about $227.3 billion available.
The market voted with money: the machine still turns.
But "the machine still turns" and "the soul is still there" are two different things.
Jones said on the call that the company wants to appoint a permanent chief executive as soon as possible but will not rush the decision just to save time. According to ifeng, Arm chief executive Rene Haas has entered discussions.
The footnote this leaves behind is roughly this:
When a person becomes the symbol of an era, his fall is never only a private matter. The crowd rushing to hold him back is often not convinced he is innocent. It simply is not ready to accept a world without him.
Trump says he learned a lesson.
The board says it does not plan to.
The 180,000 say bring him back.
Huang says he will listen to the board.
Four sentences, four orders: personal redemption, institutional process, market sentiment, performative humility.
They will not line up again. And that, in itself, is what modern society normally looks like.
Disclaimer: This article is based on public information and is for reference only; it is not investment advice.
